Skip to main content

An Open Letter to Female "Reporters": Self-Defeatism Is Self-Defeating

Dear Female Reporters and other Female PR-types,

Please quit fighting for the wrong side in the war on women.

2012 was an odd year. I know. I know. It's an even number. That's not what I meant, math nerds. I meant odd in the sense that I had absolutely no idea just how poor our STEM education really is in this country. 2012 revealed that there are men out there who believe that lady parts have a way of distinguishing a rapist's sperm from the sperm that swimmeth forth from the loins of a one true love. We also learned in this historic year, that there are people out there who actually believe that evolution means that all creatures, big and small, eventually become human.



What was even odder about 2012 was the apparent 60-year roll back in our views of women. We witnessed a presidential hopeful awestruck and muted by the simple question, "Would you have signed the Lilly Ledbetter Act?" The booby prize (pun intended) that stemmed from that debacle was the Binders Full of Women meme. Despite the promise to pass constructive legislation to create jobs, the GOP-led Congress instead focused on lady parts. Some politicians and the Susan G. Komen Foundation thought it would be a good move to try to shut down Planned Parenthood, which I argued based on personal experience would be a bad idea. In the wake of the fallout that immediately ensued, the SGK president elected to "pursue other opportunities."

I guess William Congreve was right. Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned.


While the issues above are serious issues that should be taken seriously, there are other issues that are pervasive in our society that play into this W.O.W. in more subtle ways. I'm talking about this fixation on making fun of a person's outward appearance. The other day, I came across a tweet by @HuffingtonPost that read "We think Miley Cyrus looks terrible. Are we being too harsh on her?" I clicked on the link expecting to find that Hannah Montana was being criticized unjustly by some A-hole guy who hasn't had a date in 10 years. Instead, I discovered that the piece was written by female reporter named Cristina Anderson.

Ms. Anderson's profile states that her daughter thinks her mom "gets paid to look at pretty dresses all day." While that's cute and all, I wonder how cute it would be if that byline read that Ms. Anderson's daughter thinks her mom "gets paid to pick apart the looks of young ladies and single-handedly decide who looks terrible." For the record, I really don't give a crap what Miley Cyrus does or what she wears. The last I heard, her profession is music, so if I were going to critique anything, I'd listen to her music and then make a fair assessment of whether I thought it sounded terrible or not. I wish that Ms. Anderson would do the same.

In another high-profile and *gasp* viral story, we learned that it was Beyonce's publicist--a woman--who ordered that websites remove "unflattering" photos of Bey-Bey. I'm sorry, dear readers, but if that perfect body is what one would consider "unflattering" there is absolutely no hope for yours truly. I don't know if Beyonce, herself, considered those photos unflattering or if she got a good chuckle out of the meme that resulted. Frankly, I'm too tired to do that research. I just hope that she and her publicist see the error in their ways and welcome the quite flattering unflattering body that rocked the Super Bowl halftime show with high kicks that blew the power grid.

But this got me thinking--why do women do this to ourselves? Why do we play into this petty perception that women are petty? I know we've come a long way, baby, but we're not there yet. Women leaders cannot even ask tough questions during Senate hearings without being called "extreme" and being reminded that the election is over and to "act accordingly" by the very same industry that got away scott free with contributing in a major way to the collapse of our economy. Imagine that--a US Senator who is doing her job being told how to act by a bunch of folks who quite rightly, should have seen jail time. I wonder if they would have the chutzpah to tell a male senator the same thing.

So, as you can see, ladies, the W.O.W. is far from over. We have more road ahead of us to get some R-E-S-P-E-C-T in a time that sees us slowly regressing to pre-ERA (which BTW, has not been ratified yet) times. It's bad enough that Team XY keeps doling out the hits. Don't you think it's time that Team XX quits throwing the game?

Respectfully submitted,
This Girl

Popular posts from this blog

Someone I Knew; Someone I Wish You Could Have Known

To live in hearts we leave behind Is not to die. ~Thomas Campbell, "Hallowed Ground" Fall is my favorite time of year. I love feeling the cool breeze on my face, while the sun gently warms my back. I love the colors of the leaves over my head and their crunch beneath my feet. I love the other side of the woods revealed; having been hidden for an entire season. But just as this season reveals what lies inside the depth of the woods, it reminds me of the heavy burden of loss. For the woods to come alive, the leaves must descend to their death. Why the melancholy during my favorite time of year? It was around this time some 12 years ago, when I lost a friend whom I thought would live forever. Rayna was a first year medical student at SIU. I knew her from working in the hospital. She was never without a smile and if so, it was only for a brief second, as frown turned to smirk and smirk into smile. I always knew my shift was going to be more bearable when I walked in and ...

The Non-Girlie Girl's Guide to Shopping Malls....Or, why I hate shopping

I'm an anomaly. I'm a woman, yes. I know this to be true. Just have to trust me on that one. But there is one thing that women are supposed to like that I just cannot stand. I hate the S-word. No, not that S-word. I mean shopping. In my frugal years, I thought I hated shopping because I did not like to spend money on items that I felt were over-priced. Now older and with a more lucrative job, I still don't like to part with money, but there's got to be something more to this. A recent trip to the closest shopping mall, in the midst of the fiery throngs of Suburbia, USA, enlightened my XX mind. And that's chromosomes. Stay focused! I conceded to this recent trip after a fierce negotiation with my husband (we are the married equivalent of a Union Boss and "The Suit"....not sure who's whom), who desperately wanted to go to the Apple store, but did not want to abandon me on our only day off together. Before I go any further, I must say right here and now...

Who Needs Gold When You Have Silence

I can talk. What would you like to know? Pick a topic. We'll discuss. Yes, I can talk. The problem is that so can my husband. And he is much better at it than I. But I don't mind. His love of conversation--and his skill at it--is one of the things that drew me to the big lug in the first place. But just as capable as we are at talking, we are capable of sitting in silence. And we don't think there is anything wrong with that. One of my favorite movie quotes is from When Harry Met Sally: (Harry, to Sally) "It is so nice when you can sit with someone and not have to talk." How true is that? I often joke with my husband when we are dining out that people can probably tell we've been married a long time because we are usually the only couple in the place not talking. Take note, fine, young newlyweds--some of the best conversation you will ever have will come from not conversing at all. Yes, as the old saying goes, silence is golden. After perusing other quotes a...